Makeup Marketing Partnerships That Work: Why Athlete Collabs Like Rimmel x Lily Smith Sell

Hook: Why your next beauty collab could be failing—and how athlete partnerships fix it

Finding the right creator or performer feels like searching for a needle in an industry-sized haystack: mixed metrics, conflicting audience signals, and collaborations that look great on paper but don’t move product. If you sell performance-driven cosmetics—think volumizing mascara or sweatproof foundations—you need partners who embody the claim and convert interest into bookings and purchases. That’s why modern beauty brands are turning to cross-category collaborations with athletes and performers. When done right, an athlete partnership becomes proof in motion: credibility, spectacle, and measurable ROI.

Why athlete collabs work in 2026 (and why Rimmel x Lily Smith is a useful model)

In late 2025 and early 2026, campaigns that blend high-skill physical performance with beauty product storytelling have outperformed traditional influencer ads in reach and conversion for product categories with performance claims—mascara PR being a prime example. The Rimmel campaign with Red Bull and gymnast Lily Smith offers a clear blueprint: a stunt with authentic skill, institutional credibility, and tightly aligned messaging that proves the product claim in an unforgettable visual.

“Performing this routine in such a unique and unusual setting, ahead of my college season, was a total thrill for me,” said Lily Smith, who also appears in Rimmel’s global marketing for its Thrill Seeker Mega Lift Mascara.

Key reasons this model works in 2026:

• Authentic claim alignment: Athletes naturally validate “long-wear,” “lift,” and “sweat-resistant” claims by putting products through real-world stress.
• High-impact content formats: Short-form video, vertical stunts, and live drops perform well on platforms where discovery and purchase intent intersect.
• Cross-audience amplification: Athlete fandom brings new audience segments—sports fans, performance communities, and lifestyle media—without diluting beauty credibility.
• PR-friendly spectacle: A rooftop balance beam 52 stories up is headline news; earned media multiplies paid spend.
• Stronger measurement: Performance-based experiments (incrementality tests) in 2026 allow brands to isolate collaboration impact more reliably than vanity metrics alone.

How to pick the right athlete or performer: the brand-fit checklist

Choosing a talent isn’t just about follower count. Use this practical checklist to match a performer to product claims and audience needs. Score candidates from 1–5 on each item; prioritize those with highest totals.

1. Product-Claim Fit (1–5)
   • Does their activity naturally stress the product claim? (e.g., gymnasts for lift/sweatproof mascara, surfers for SPF foundations)
2. Audience Overlap (1–5)
   • How closely does their primary audience match your buyer persona?
3. Authenticity & Story (1–5)
   • Do they already talk about beauty, performance, or personal care in a natural way?
4. Content Capability (1–5)
   • Can they create high-quality short-form and long-form content, or do they need production support?
5. Brand Safety & Values (1–5)
   • Does their public behavior align with your brand values—diversity, sustainability, inclusivity?
6. Exclusive Access & PR Potential (1–5)
   • Do they create opportunities for stunts, press, or experiential activations?
7. Commercial Terms Fit (1–5)
   • Are their rates and licensing requirements realistic for your budget and expected ROI?

Quick scoring rule

Sum scores; prioritise candidates scoring above 25/35. Use weighted scores if product-fit matters more than audience size for your launch.

Designing the campaign: creative concepts that sell mascara and more

Athlete collaborations must answer two questions quickly: 1) What does this product do? 2) Why is this the only product that makes that possible? Use these creative pillars as a structure:

• Proof-in-action: The athlete performs a task that directly demonstrates the claim—e.g., a routine showing no smudge, extreme lift or movement.
• Behind-the-scenes authenticity: Quick cutaways to real prep, candid talk about routine and why the product matters to them.
• Data-backed voice: Integrate quantified claims (e.g., “up to 6x visible volume”) and show lab or in-market data in short overlays.
• Interactive commerce moments: Live shopping or shoppable short-form clips where viewers can buy or book immediately.
• Stunt + narrative: Combine spectacle (high-altitude beam) with human story (training, nerves, community).

Practical production tips for stunt-based beauty activations

Stunts like the Rimmel rooftop routine require meticulous planning. Here’s a production checklist to reduce risk and amplify ROI.

• Safety & permits: Secure permits, build redundancies, and document insurance—PR can’t outweigh preventable risk.
• Pre-test the product under stress: Run lab and field tests that mirror stunt conditions and keep the documentation for claims defense and PR.
• Capture multiple angles: Film vertical, landscape, and high frame-rate slow motion for social platforms and earned media packages.
• Microcontent from macro moments: Slice the stunt into 6–15 second clips, 30–60 second hero spots, and BTS for Stories/Reels.
• Real-time engagement: Plan a live element (countdown, Q&A, limited bundles) that lets athletes interact with fans immediately after the stunt.

Measurement: how to prove campaign ROI in 2026

Brand PR and spectacle are great for awareness, but modern CMOs demand clarity. Use a layered measurement approach:

1. Short-term commerce metrics: Conversion rate on shoppable clips, promo-code redemptions, and conversion lift vs. control landing pages.
2. Attention & engagement metrics: View-through rate (VTR) on short-form, watch time, reaction rate, and live engagement spikes.
3. Incrementality tests: Split-audience experiments on paid media to isolate the campaign’s causal impact on sales.
4. Earned media value: PR placements, AVE estimates, and referral traffic spikes from editorial sites and sports media.
5. Long-term brand effects: Brand lift surveys and consideration lift measured over 60–90 days post-campaign.

Key KPI examples for a mascara launch in 2026:

• Shoppable clip CTR target: 2–4%
• Conversion rate on campaign landing page: 6–12% (higher when bundled with free shipping/limited gifts)
• Incremental ROAS target: 3x+ over baseline campaigns
• Earned media pick-up: 5–15 high-quality outlets (beauty, lifestyle, sports)

Legal, ethical, and authenticity guardrails

Brands must protect claims and trust. In 2026, regulators and platforms are tighter about performance claims and deceptive practices. Follow these guardrails:

• Document testing: Keep lab and field-test documents that support claims like “up to 6x volume.”
• Clear disclosures: All paid content must be labeled per platform rules and local advertising law (e.g., #ad, #sponsored).
• Consent & image rights: Secure global licensing rights if content will air in multiple territories.
• Safety-first scripts: No copy that encourages unsafe behavior; if stunts are used, make safety messaging visible.
• AI & deepfake policy: If using synthetic enhancements (e.g., to demo product effects), disclose them clearly. Platforms and consumers penalize undisclosed AI manipulation.

Channel mix for maximum impact

Amplify athlete-led campaigns across channels tuned for behavior in 2026:

• Short-form social (TikTok/Shorts/Reels): Primary discovery channel—use vertical hero clips and shoppable tags.
• Live commerce & livestreams: Integrate athlete Q&As and bundle drops in live shopping windows to increase conversion velocity.
• Paid social & programmatic video: Use creative variants informed by short-form performance; retarget viewers with product-specific offers.
• Earned & trade PR: Pitch lifestyle and sports outlets with stunt packages, athlete bios, and behind-the-scenes footage.
• Retail partnerships & in-store displays: Bring stunt photography and short-loop videos to retail screens to create point-of-sale saliency.
• AR try-on: Allow users to try the mascara virtually in-app or within social AR lenses—ties digital interest to physical trials.

Case study breakdown: Rimmel x Lily Smith (what to copy, what to adapt)

The Rimmel collaboration scaled a core idea: match an extreme performer to an extreme claim. Here are the translatable tactics and what you should adapt for different brands and budgets.

What to copy

• Authentic task-based proof: The beam showcased lift and resilience—exactly what a mascara needs to prove.
• Partnership amplification: Teaming with Red Bull connected sports media and lifestyle press beyond beauty beats.
• Hero + microcontent: The stunt became hero content for campaign spots and dozens of short repurposed clips.

What to adapt

• Budget-scaled stunts: Not every brand can build a rooftop set—consider competition formats, training montages, or local pop-up activations with verified athletes.
• Micro-athlete strategy: Use local or collegiate athletes for community resonance and cost-effective content pipelines.
• Measurement sophistication: Pair spectacle with immediate commerce hooks and A/B tests so spend shows immediate ROI.

Selecting athletes in 2026: advanced strategies

New tools in 2026 make selection faster and safer:

• AI-driven talent-matching: Platforms now analyze audience overlap, content style, sentiment, and fake-follower risk to recommend fits.
• Performance micro-bundles: Instead of a single hero athlete, book a cohort of specialists (gymnasts, dancers, yogis) for content diversity and layered reach.
• Fan-token engagement: Use limited NFTs or tokenized access to the athlete event for higher AOV bundles—use with caution and clear regulatory compliance.

Actionable playbook: 8-step collaboration strategy

1. Define the claim and audience: Translate the product claim into a specific on-camera task and match to audiences who care about that activity.
2. Score & shortlist athletes: Use the scoring checklist above and create an audition set of short videos (real or test shoots).
3. Prototype content: Produce a low-cost microscale proof (e.g., gym floor shoot) to test creative hooks and messaging.
4. Finalize partnership terms: Include usage, exclusivity windows, and performance KPIs tied to bonuses.
5. Plan multi-channel rollout: Coordinate hero drop, follow-up social, live commerce slot, and PR seeding in a 30–60 day window.
6. Measure & iterate: Run incrementality tests and optimize creative and spend weekly in the first 30 days.
7. Leverage earned media: Share BTS and stunt details with targeted press lists and sports outlets for secondary pickups.
8. Extend the story: Follow the athlete across their season for episodic content and sustained conversion windows.

Red flags and fail-safe moves

Watch for these risks and how to mitigate them:

• Misaligned spectacle: If the performance doesn’t directly prove the product claim, audiences see it as a gimmick. Fix: Pivot creative or choose a performer whose skillset maps directly to the claim.
• Poor measurement design: Without controls, you can’t prove lift. Fix: Build A/B or geo-split tests before the drop.
• Overreliance on earned PR: Don’t depend solely on headlines—plan paid amplifications targeted to conversion audiences.
• Unclear disclosures: Failing to disclose paid relationships creates trust issues and regulatory risk. Fix: Standardize disclosure language and auditing.

Final takeaways: why brand fit matters more than follower counts

In 2026, the most successful beauty collaborations are precise matches: performer skill maps to product claim, creative marries spectacle to proof, and measurement ties media to sales. The Rimmel x Lily Smith example shows the power of aligning spectacle with specification—an athlete’s skill acting as live validation for a product’s promise. For brands, that means investing time in selection, testing early, and designing for purchase paths from day one.

Call to action

Ready to plan a high-impact athlete partnership that actually sells? Download our 1-page Athlete-Collab Checklist and Campaign KPI template, or connect with our creative partners at BeautyExperts.app to vet talent, run prototype shoots, and set up incrementality tests. Turn proof into performance—book a consultation and start designing a collaboration that fits your brand and moves product.

Related Reading

• When to Sprint and When to Marathon Your Transit Technology Rollout
• Warm Feet, Happy Walks: Choosing the Right Shetland Insoles and Slippers for Rugged Weather
• What Broadcom’s Rise Means for Quantum Hardware Suppliers and Qubit Control Electronics
• Scalable Backend Patterns for Crowdsourced Map Alerts (Waze-style) and a React Native Client
• Best Budget Wireless Charging Stations: Why the UGREEN MagFlow Qi2 Is Worth the 32% Off